Chaosium has indefinitely suspended development of its recently crowdfunded board game Call of Cthulhu: Old Ones Origins after learning that lead designer Samuel William Bailey was convicted on multiple felony charges in Washington state.
The publisher announced the decision on November 15, 2026, just one month after the project completed a highly successful Gamefound campaign. According to Chaosium, the company was first informed of Bailey’s criminal case on November 13 and subsequently verified the information before issuing a public statement and halting all work on the project.
Conviction Leads to Immediate Suspension
Bailey was convicted on November 12, 2026, in Skagit County, Washington, on multiple felony counts, including first-degree rape of a minor and child molestation. Court records indicate the offenses occurred between June 2022 and June 2023. He is scheduled to be sentenced on December 10, 2026, and the convictions carry the possibility of a lengthy prison sentence.
In its public statement, Chaosium described the crimes as having “significant legal implications” for the project in addition to the obvious moral concerns. The company stated that it had no prior knowledge of either the allegations or the ongoing criminal proceedings until being contacted after the verdict.
“We have stopped all development on this project,” Chaosium wrote, adding that it is working with legal counsel to determine the most appropriate path forward for both the company and its backers.
A Crowdfunding Success Suddenly in Limbo
The announcement comes as a shock to nearly 3,000 supporters who backed the game on Gamefound. The campaign raised approximately $769,861 from 2,979 backers, averaging roughly $258 per pledge.
Originally positioned as a major tabletop release for 2027, Old Ones Origins attracted significant attention for adapting the mechanical foundations of Forbidden Stars into Chaosium’s Call of Cthulhu universe. Bailey’s involvement was considered a key selling point of the campaign, as he was one of the co-designers of the popular 2015 strategy game Forbidden Stars.
At the time development was halted, Chaosium had been preparing for the next phases of production and fulfillment. The company also reportedly worked with Gamefound to stop upcoming StretchPay installment charges, although some payments may have already processed due to banking and timing constraints.
Questions About the Future of the Project
For now, the future of Call of Cthulhu: Old Ones Origins remains uncertain.
Chaosium has not announced whether the project will be canceled outright, refunded, reworked under new leadership, or revived without Bailey’s involvement. The publisher has stated only that legal and contractual issues must be addressed before any final decisions can be made.
Industry observers have noted that the situation presents complex questions regarding intellectual property rights, designer compensation, contractual obligations, and backer expectations. Whether Chaosium can continue development while fully separating the project from its designer remains unclear.
Wider Industry Impact
The controversy has prompted broader discussion throughout the tabletop gaming industry regarding due diligence, background checks, and publisher relationships with freelance designers. Several reports noted that criminal charges against Bailey had been a matter of public record for years prior to the conviction, although background investigations of independent game designers are uncommon within the industry.
The case has also reignited conversations about transparency in crowdfunding projects, particularly when a campaign’s marketing heavily emphasizes the involvement of a specific designer.
Awaiting Further Updates
Chaosium has pledged to keep backers informed as additional information becomes available. Until legal reviews are completed, the company says no further decisions regarding refunds, project continuation, or fulfillment will be announced.
For the thousands of supporters who backed the project and the wider tabletop gaming community, all eyes are now on Chaosium’s next move as it navigates one of the most significant and unexpected controversies in recent board gaming history.
Discover more from DDO Players
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

